‘THE RULE OF JENNY PEN’ (2025) Geoffrey Rush and John Lithgow stun in a disquieting ping pong match of cruelty and power.

IFC Shudder LogoTHE RULE OF JENNY PEN


The rule of Jenny Pen posterAfter suffering a stroke, Stefan must convalesce in an assisted living facility that also houses a psychotic patient who tortures the residents with a creepy hand puppet. Based on Owen Marshall‘s short story, James Ashcroft brings THE RULE OF JENNY PEN to life in all its skin-crawling glory.

Stefan immediately recognizes Dave exerting control over the other residents, and his curmudgeonly, hard-nosed approach to those around him softens. His life dedicated to fairness emboldens him to level the playing field, even if that means drastically adjusting his moral compass.

THE RULE OF JENNY PEN
–
Still 1
–
John Lithgow as
“
Dave Crealy
”,
Geoffrey Rush as
“
Stefan
Mortensen
”,
and Jenny Pen in James Ashcroft
’
s THE RULE OF JENNY PEN. Courtesy of Matt Henley.
An IFC Films and Shudder Release.

John Lithgow as “Dave Crealy”, Geoffrey Rush as “Stefan Mortensen”, and Jenny Pen in James Ashcroft’s THE RULE OF JENNY PEN. Courtesy of Matt Henley. An IFC Films and Shudder Release.

Geoffrey Rush is Stefan Mortensen. As a man who built of career on doling out justice, the utter lack of control is physical and mental torture. Rush is spectacular. His stubborn, unrelenting sense of righting the wrong makes him easy to root for.

John Lithgow is Dave Crealy. His character is a cruel menace. Lithgow’s physical stature plays a key role. He is at least a head taller than the rest of the cast, easily dominating any space. Crealy is a ticking time bomb. Lithgow leans into his irrationality like a pro. It is terrifying. Rush and Lithgow go toe to toe in a fascinating tennis match of chaos and vitriol. It is a masterclass.

THE RULE OF JENNY PEN -Geoffrey Rush as “Stefan Mortensen” in James Ashcroft’s THE RULE OF JENNY PEN. Courtesy of Matt Henley. An IFC Films and Shudder Release.

Geoffrey Rush as “Stefan Mortensen” in James Ashcroft’s THE RULE OF JENNY PEN. Courtesy of Matt Henley. An IFC Films and Shudder Release.

The augmented sound editing by John Mackay and Matthew Lambourn is particularly challenging if, like me, you are prone to overstimulation. Frankly, the entire film is similarly structured. Matt Henley’s camera work is intentional, with close-ups that feel invasive in the best way. Gretchen Peterson’s editing reminds us that while Stefan is undeniably brilliant, his mind and body are failing him. Ashcroft and co-writer Eli Kent weaponize lost time and immobility. The infantilization of patients is heartbreaking and uncomfortable.

THE RULE OF JENNY PEN is a bleak but captivating watch. It reminds us how we treat our elderly once deemed socially inconvenient. The script delves into power structure, unresolved trauma, and the consequences of unchecked evil. THE RULE OF JENNY PEN is something greater than sinister.

THE RULE OF JENNY PEN -Jenny Pen in James Ashcroft’s THE RULE OF JENNY PEN. Courtesy of Matt Henley. An IFC Films and Shudder Release.

Jenny Pen in James Ashcroft’s THE RULE OF JENNY PEN. Courtesy of Matt Henley. An IFC Films and Shudder Release.

THE RULE OF JENNY PEN Trailer:

IN THEATERS THIS FRIDAY, MARCH 7TH

Synopsis

Arrogant Judge Stefan Mortensen (Rush) suffers a near-fatal stroke, leaving him partially paralyzed and confined to a retirement home. Resistant to the staff and distant from his friendly roommate, Mortensen soon clashes with seemingly gentle resident Dave Crealy (Lithgow) who secretly terrorizes the home with a sadistic game called “The Rule of Jenny Pen” while wielding his dementia doll as an instrument of cruelty. What begins as childish torment quickly escalates into far more sinister and disturbing incidents. When Mortensen’s pleas to the staff go unanswered, he takes it upon himself to put an end to Crealy’s reign of terror.

About The Director

James Ashcroft formed Light in the Dark Productions in 2014, specializing in contemporary screen adaptations from New Zealand’s literary canon. His feature film directing debut Coming Home in the Dark premiered at the Sundance Film Festival 2021 to great acclaim, followed by a global festival tour. He is currently working on a slate of features in the US including Max Brooks’ Devolution and Grady Hendrix’ How To Sell A Haunted House, for Legendary Studios and Sam Raimi’s Ghost House Pictures, The Whisper Man for the Russo Brother’s AGBO Productions/Netflix and an adaptation of the graphic novel Old Haunts for AWA Studios.

He attended the Venice Biennale Cinema College as one of 12 teams selected worldwide. He was also one of 15 director/producers selected for the Torino Film Festivals inaugural Up & Coming Programme, showcasing talent from around the world. From 2006-2013, Ashcroft served as Artistic Director and Chief Executive of national Maori theatre company Taki Rua Productions, developing and touring New Zealand works both nationally and internationally. Ashcroft is a graduate of Victoria University and Toi Whakaari: New Zealand Drama School. He has served internships with acclaimed theatre company The Wooster Group in New York.

 

Director: James Ashcroft

Screenwriters: Eli Kent, James Ashcroft

Cast: John Lithgow, Geoffrey Rush

Producers: Catherine Fitzgerald, Orlando Stewart

Executive Producers: James Ashcroft, Eli Kent, John Lithgow, Geoffrey Rush, Emily Gotto, Nicholas Lazo, Samuel Zimmerman 

Director of Photography: Matt Henley

Editor: Gretchen Peterson

Composer: John Gibson  

Language: English

Country: New Zealand

Running Time: 103 minutes

For more coverage of IFC Shudder films, click here!

About Liz Whittemore

Liz grew up in northern Connecticut and was memorizing movie dialogue from Shirley Temple to A Nightmare on Elm Street at a very early age. She will watch just about any film all the way through (no matter how bad) just to prove a point. A loyal New Englander, a lover of Hollywood, and true inhabitant of The Big Apple.

Leave a Reply